SIP vs FD
A fixed deposit promises a known return. A SIP offers a higher expected return with an unknown path. The interesting part is what happens after tax and inflation — a “safe” FD can quietly lose purchasing power.
Short answer: use FDs for money you need soon or cannot risk. Use SIPs for goals at least seven years away. A 7% FD taxed at 30% leaves about 4.9%; if inflation is 6%, the real return is negative.
Side-by-side
| Feature | Equity SIP | Fixed deposit |
|---|---|---|
| Return | Market-linked; 10%–12% long-term assumption | Fixed at booking, around 6.5%–7.5% |
| Risk | Market risk; falls possible | Low credit risk; insured up to ₹5 lakh per bank |
| Tax | 12.5% LTCG above ₹1.25 lakh on equity funds | Interest taxed at your slab every year |
| Liquidity | Redeem any business day | Breakable with a penalty; otherwise locked |
| Inflation protection | Historically positive real returns over long periods | Often negative after tax and inflation |
| Best for | Goals 7+ years away | Emergency funds and short-term goals |
₹10,000 a month for 15 years
Assume a 12% return for the SIP and 7% for the FD. Both invest ₹18,00,000 in total.
| Equity SIP | Fixed deposit | |
|---|---|---|
| Total invested | ₹18,00,000 | ₹18,00,000 |
| Value after 15 years | ₹50,45,760 | ₹31,88,112 |
| Gain | ₹32,45,760 | ₹13,88,112 |
| Tax (approx.) | ₹3,90,095 | ₹4,16,434 |
| Post-tax value | ₹46,55,665 | ₹27,71,678 |
The FD is taxed every year on the interest, at your marginal slab. The approximation above assumes a 30% rate. For someone in the 20% slab the FD looks better, but it still trails the SIP scenario — and both figures ignore inflation.
The inflation problem
A 7% FD taxed at 30% returns about 4.9% after tax. With 6% inflation, its real return is roughly −1% a year. The balance grows in rupees, but it buys less. Over 15 years, that gap compounds against you.
This is why “safe” needs a definition. An FD is safe in nominal terms — you will not see the balance fall. It is not safe in real terms if the goal is decades away.
When an FD is the right tool
- Emergency fund: three to six months of expenses, instantly accessible.
- Goals within 1–3 years: a wedding, a car, a tax payment.
- Capital you cannot afford to lose: near-retirement money or a house deposit.
- Laddering: splitting deposits across maturities to smooth interest-rate changes.
When a SIP is the right tool
- Retirement: a 15–30 year horizon gives equity time to recover from bad years.
- Child education: long horizons and rising costs make real growth important.
- Wealth building: you can tolerate paper losses without selling.
The practical split
Keep the emergency fund and any money needed within three years in deposits or liquid funds. Put long-term money on a SIP, and increase the contribution each year with a step-up plan. Then check what the corpus is really worth with the inflation-adjusted calculator.
Assumptions: constant 12% SIP return, 7% FD rate, 30% tax slab, no inflation adjustment in the table. Real returns vary, FD rates change, and tax rules differ by country and year.
Frequently asked questions
Is SIP better than FD?
For long-term goals, an equity SIP has a higher expected return, but it carries market risk. A fixed deposit is predictable and capital-protected, which makes it better for money you need soon or cannot afford to see fall. The right choice depends on the horizon and the job the money has to do.
Why can an FD lose money in real terms?
Because interest is taxed and inflation erodes purchasing power. A 7% FD in the 30% tax slab leaves about 4.9% after tax. If inflation is 6%, the real return is roughly −1% a year: the deposit grows in rupees but buys less over time.
What returns can I expect from a SIP?
Equity mutual funds are not guaranteed. Over long periods, many planners model 10%–12% a year before tax for diversified equity portfolios, but actual results vary and can be negative over a decade. Always test a conservative rate as well.
Are fixed deposits risk-free?
They carry low credit risk when held with a scheduled bank, and deposits are insured by DICGC up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank. They are not immune to inflation or tax risk, and corporate deposits or NBFC deposits carry additional credit risk.
Should I keep both?
Yes, often. An emergency fund of three to six months of expenses belongs in a deposit or liquid fund, not in equity. Money for goals more than seven years away can go into a SIP. Keeping the two pots separate makes it easier to stay invested when markets fall.